Realtors divide Old Town into two parts: Old Town North-of-Truman: White Street to Fort Street and south to Truman. The Key West Cemetery and Bahama Village are located here. Old Town South-of-Truman: Definitions vary but generally it is Leon on the east to Fort Street on the west. Truman to United on the south with a soft line between Old Town and the Casa Marina District.
An additional resource, USA.com provides Census and other data on Key West and its varied neighborhoods.
The Key West Association of Realtors provides an excellent map detailing the neighborhoods and streets of each of the neighborhoods.
Search For Property in Old Town